| Girls | Boys | |||
| Year | Name | School | Name | School |
| 2009 | Nichole Purvis | Arkansas | Chris Cifone | Ohio |
| 2008 | Marissa Helms | Kentucky | Chad Rohr | Kansas |
| 2007 | Katie Robinson | Ohio | Michael White | Indiana |
| 2006 | Mika Baugh | Indiana | Corey Grandstaff | Ohio |
| 2005 | Heather Oklak | Indiana | Dylan Krenske | Minnesota |
| 2004 | Breina Morris | Indiana | Adnan Gutic | Missouri |
| 2003 | Ashley Wasmond | Wisconsin | Ron Hawthorne | Kansas |